1840-60

• Andrew Wylie, 1841-51

1870-90

• John Lenoir Gay, 1871-73
• Property purchased at 7th and College.
• 1872; frame church built
• John H. Euchbaum, 1877-78
• Frank Pearce Harrington, 1879
• Abraham Reeves, 1881-82
• Douglas Irving Hobbs, 1884
• Richard Colgate Talbot, 1885-86
• Augustine Prentiss, 1887
• Frank Lewis Cole, 1888-90

1900-20

• Edward Saunders, 1891-93
• 1889-90 7th and College property sold; frame church built at Kirkwood and Grant (present location)
• George E. Swan, 1894
• Charles H. Schultz, 1886-97
• Laurancc Thomas Cole, 1898
• William P Cook, 1900
• Gilbert M. Foxwell, 1900-01
• Abron Kinney Hall, 1901-02
• Elijah E. Edwards, 1903
• William M. Walton, 1903-05
• John Henry Heady, 1905-08
• William Burrows, 1909-25
• 1909 Stone church built; old building to rear of lot used for Vicarage.
• 1911 St. Margaret's Hall purchased by Diocese, home for Christian women students
• 1920-50
• A. Elliston Cole, 1925-60
• 1942 Parish status achieved

1960-70

• William A. Eddy, 1961-67
• 1962 Trinity Steps Forward campaign
• 1965 Purchase of property in Blue Ridge
• Charles A. Perry, 1968-70
• 1969 Build Now campaign
• 1970 New classroom building constructed on the site of St. Margaret's Hall and old vicarage
• Donald J. Davis, 1971-73

1970-90

• Hugh C. Laughlin, 1974-98
• 1974-83 New organ constructed
• 1975 Christus Rex installed
• 1989 Dedication of Great Hall and Columbarium
• 1990 Bloomington Nativity Collection established
• 1992 Courtyard garden completed
• Edward W. Jones, 1999-2000

2000

• Donald A. Jones, 2000-06
• Kenneth L. Ornell, 2007-08
• Charlie Dupree, 2008